Early on the morning of October 14, 2022, Pastor Sara Keeling was awakened by a neighbor’s call: “I think there’s a fire at the church!” Then she and others hurried outside…and watched as firefighters battled a major fire in our church building.
Now almost a year later, Open the Doors is our capital campaign to pay for reconstruction costs not covered by our insurance. Removal of asbestos-containing material was mostly but not fully covered, for instance.

A big expense is replacing the roof—joints, rafters, slate and all—because our reimbursement is based on depreciated roof value, not replacement value. Safety-monitoring system updates are merited, as well as professional advice and solving problems yet to be uncovered.
The fire started in the attic (old wiring was the presumed cause) and burned the roof and the attic’s contents, leaving only a blackened pile of ash and debris. While active flames were contained to the attic, efforts to extinguish the fire created extensive smoke and water damage.
.jpg)
Fire trucks sprayed thousands of gallons of water on the second-floor music room and classrooms, the first-floor staff offices and Gathering Space, and the lower-level classrooms.
Immediately after the fire, Mount Olivet hired Paul Davis Restoration, a fire recovery contractor, to clean the building, remove damaged contents, and seal the fire-damaged area off from the rest of the building.
Our priority was making the weekday preschool classrooms, sanctuary, fellowship hall, and remaining classroom spaces safe for use. Mount Olivet also formed a fire recovery committee— the Phoenix Taskforce — to engage with Church Mutual, the Church’s property insurance agency, as well as Paul Davis Restoration, to assess the damage.
.jpg)
Repair and recovery
Environmental testing revealed that fire and water damage had exposed materials containing asbestos in the fire-damaged area of the building. No restoration could begin until these asbestos-containing materials were removed. Asbestos abatement was completed on August 18, 2023, and all spaces were re-tested and cleared for restoration.
Now the Phoenix Taskforce is meeting with contractors to tour the building and gather comprehensive proposals for all repair work. Mount Olivet has contracted with an architect to prepare drawings to submit to Arlington County for construction permits.

We’d like to raise at least $500,000 to support the repairs to the building, and get a restored building ready for Mount Olivet’s ministries as soon as is feasible. Mount Olivet’s goal is to open the doors — OUR doors — in the fall of 2024. With your help, we believe that is possible!
(Should funds raised from this campaign exceed the final costs of the restoration and repair of the damage due from the fire, any excess will be used to support long-standing capital repairs and projects.)
What can I do to support Open the Doors?
We’d like you to pray and reflect on what the Lord is calling you to do to fulfill the Lord’s will for Mount Olivet. While amounts may be different for everyone, our hope is that each person will be led to give generously.
Message from Leadership
Dear Members and Friends,
Commitments to our Open the Doors capital fundraising campaign are critical for Mount Olivet’s missions, including Community Assistance, the Preschool, music ministry, youth ministry, The Way, and Traditional Worship. Please give generously.
Sara Keeling, Senior Pastor
Kristen Nelson and Justin Kopca, Open the Doors Co-Chairs
Open the Doors is our capital campaign to repair and reclaim the space closed since October 14, 2022, when a fire and water damaged all levels of that portion of our beloved Mount Olivet building.
Open the Doors alludes to opening the plastic-shrouded doors that lead from our Sanctuary to the Gathering Space, as well as opening the 16th Street and the Glebe Road doors for our mission and ministries, not only for our congregation, but for our community.
The fire started in the attic and burned the roof structure and the contents of the attic. Once the fire was out, all that remained of the attic was a blackened pile of ash and debris. While the active fire was contained to the attic, efforts to extinguish the fire created extensive smoke and water damage as fire trucks from Arlington, Fairfax County, and Alexandria sprayed thousands of gallons of water on the second-floor choir room and classrooms, the Church staff offices on the first floor, our Gathering Space, and the lower-level classrooms.
Immediately after the fire, Mount Olivet hired Paul Davis Restoration, a fire recovery contractor, to secure and clean the building and remove damaged contents. Paul Davis installed fans, provided smoke cleaning services, and sealed the fire damaged area off from the rest of the building.
Emphasis was placed on making the weekday preschool classes, sanctuary, fellowship hall, and remaining classroom spaces safe for use. Shortly after the fire occurred, Mount Olivet also formed a fire recovery committee called the Phoenix Taskforce to engage with Church Mutual, the Church’s property insurance agency, as well as Paul Davis Restoration, to assess the damage and the extensive repairs necessary to reclaim the space.
Over the past several months, the Mount Olivet weekly E-news, website, and the Sunday bulletins have provided updates of all actions and repairs to the fire damaged side of the building. From these updates, we have learned that Paul Davis conducted environmental testing during the emergency response process.
The testing revealed that fire and water damage exposed materials containing asbestos in the fire damaged area of the building. No restoration work could begin until these asbestos containing materials were removed and the spaces were retested.
Asbestos abatement was completed on August 18, 2023 and all spaces were re-tested and cleared for restoration. Now that asbestos abatement is completed, the Phoenix Taskforce is in the process of meeting with contractors to tour the building and gather comprehensive proposals for all repair work.
In the meantime, Mount Olivet has contracted with an architect who will prepare drawings to submit to Arlington County for construction permits.
Since November 2022, the Phoenix Taskforce has worked closely with Church Mutual to determine the amount of funds we will receive for the fire restoration work due under our insurance policy.
Unfortunately, there are some limits on what our insurance policy will pay for to restore the space for reopening. We have incurred out of pocket expenses for asbestos abatement and will have additional expenses for the roof repair as well as some security system requirements.
All of these expenses are critical to the safety and security of the church. The Open the Doors capital campaign will support these expenses not covered by insurance and ensure our building can open without further delays
The Open the Doors capital campaign has the goal of raising at least $500,000 to support the restoration and repairs to the building. Raising $500,000 will ensure that the Phoenix Taskforce will be able to guide the work in a flexible, creative, and financially responsible manner.
The result will be a building restored and ready for Mount Olivet’s future ministries.Should funds raised from this campaign exceed the final costs of the restoration and repair of the damage due from the fire, the excess funds will be used to support long-standing capital repairs and projects.
The only expectation is that each person pray and reflect on what the Lord is calling you to do to fulfill the Lord’s will for Mount Olivet and respond to this call. While amounts may be different for everyone, our hope is that each person will be led by God to give generously and sacrificially.
Over the next several weeks, you will receive or can pick up a commitment card to pledge your support to this campaign. We ask that you pray about the commitment you wish to make.
Once you determine your commitment, you can:
– return the commitment card to an offering plate that will be placed in front of the closed doors in the sanctuary.
– contact Marilyn Traynham and let her know of your commitment.
– Submit your commitment card online using the form on this page.
You may spread your giving over 36 months (until October 2026) to fulfill your commitment.
We ask that you indicate your commitment as soon as possible but no later than Sunday, October 15. On that day, we will have a special service dedicated to prayer and reflection on this campaign and our vision of the future of this restored space.
Open the Doors is not our annual stewardship campaign - that will be later this fall. Your tithe or offering supports the ongoing mission and ministry of Mount Olivet and should always be your first priority. Please do not reduce what you are already giving to Mount Olivet. Open the Doors is an opportunity to give above and beyond your regular gift.
You can speak to Pastor Sara Keeling, Marilyn Traynham, Church Administrator, or Sarah Young, Chair of the Phoenix Taskforce, if you have specific questions on the repairs of the space.
Plans and activities for the continued restoration of the space and the building are ongoing. If architectural drawings can be submitted to Arlington County this fall, we hope to begin construction in January or February of 2024. Based on this timeframe and barring any unforeseen circumstances, the construction will take several months to complete. Our goal is to open the doors in the fall of 2024.